Science, Bias, and Presuppositions

Share this post via email










Submit

Again and again the themes of science, bias, and presupppositions kept cropping up all across the blogosphere today.


Across the Blogosphere (...I didn't even like that movie)

So, I have to talk about.

The first post was Mike Brotherton's rant against homeschooling. Well, not homeschooling, but the problems with "religious indoctrination" when it comes to science. Basically, he doesn't like "science fairs" where all exhibits should include a Scripture reference and relate all areas of science to the Creator of the universe. This is intellectually dishonest, and has very little to do with science, especially since the list of suggested topics contains a bunch of "why" questions... something which science can't answer. In short, we're starting with a presupposition and working toward it.

Then I hit a fascinating, and rather pointed, post by Stephen Douglas about Why Creationists are Creationists. He states that Creationists have a beef with Evolutionary Theory not on the grounds of science, but rather on the basis of their theological beliefs about the nature of the Genesis account.

Other people were talking about this as well, so I feel the need to jump in.

1. It's true: In the cited cases these are not science questions and have nothing to do with the scientific method.

2. From my observation, however, much of the study of evolution has been done largely apart from the scientific method as well: We simply can't 1. Use our experience to 2. Form a conjecture whereby we can 3. Deduce a prediction and then 4. Test--Wikipedia--when it comes to forming new species. Instead, we have to rely on other observations, ideas, and thought-experiments. We look through what we currently have and try to figure out why that may be the case.

3. While there is compelling research which is producing very interesting cases for an evolutionary origin of the many species we have around us--some of which is not questioned by anyone; like, the many variations of dogs we have--I'm fairly confident there are actual scientific reasons to distrust the hypotheses of full-blown evolutionism.

4. It is true that Creationists come at these questions with a strong bias, but I think there is true scientific inquiry in some cases. On the other hand, Evolutionists come at these questions with their own strong bias, but they too engage in true scientific inquiry.

We simply can't escape our presuppositions. They are the basis--the bias--from which we operate. I've been reading my dad's blog with much interest as he wrestles with some of the evidence that is out there. It has been very informative and I have been looking into things on my own a little as well. And in my findings I came across a guy who said that the fossil record is constantly revealing the "missing links" between the species.

My wife, an archeology minor in college, rolled her eyes. "That's ridiculous," she said. "The only reason they are finding that kind of thing is because that's the only thing that you can get a grant for. I'd have to see actual evidence, and not just hear about it from someone who wants to find that kind of thing. The field of archeology simply isn't that cut and dry. There is no motivation to find variations within a species, only to find new species because that's what makes the headlines."

This post is already way too long, but I think my point is this: Our presuppositions dictate our biases. We have them, but we should allow them to be challenged. The problem I see is that many people write off the other side as either willfully ignorant--I've heard "f-ing retards" more than once--or evil and mislead--I've seen the equivalent of "godless heathen" more than once as well. From what I've seen, there is yet little truly convincing science on either side.

Though, despite that bias, I'm willing to hear the evidence, and I'll try to keep my brain engaged when you start presenting your ideas.

 ~Luke Holzmann
Filmmaker, Writer, Expectant Father

Share this post via email










Submit
12 Comments

Natural Born Learners

Share this post via email










Submit

(What better title for a Valentine's Day post than an allusion to a film about murdering psychopaths, right? [NB: I have not seen the aforementioned film])

How about some love?

Some homeschooling love, that is!

Dave, the brilliant artist who did the artwork for the covers of the MathTacular series, sent me a link to bornlearning.org. I haven't had time to really delve into the content of the site, but it looks like a great promotion for homeschooling.

...but it's not.

At least, it's not aware that it's a site dedicated to homeschooling. Instead, it seems to believe that it is about preparing children for school; in their words, they're trying to "boost school readiness."

It would be incredibly amusing, if it weren't so sad, that people so often miss the link between caring for your newborn and growing children and homeschooling. I want to shout: IT'S THE SAME THING!

Teaching your children to read is little different than teaching them to walk. Helping your daughter learn to eat with utensils is very similar to teaching her handwriting. Getting your son to know when to say "Geese" instead of "Gooses" is much like teaching him to spell. And if your child learned 2+2 while still at home, you've started teaching Algebra*. And so, this site dedicated to "early learning" is demonstrating how easy, possible, and enjoyable it is to teach your children at home, at the park, and on the go.

That's a lesson homeschooling parents all over the world have learned.

I just wish that educational theorists would learn this lesson as well. It amazes me that despite having an entire section dedicated to the importance of connection in learning, the good people at bornlearning.org do not connect the dots and realize that homeschooling is one of the best ways to make that happen.

So...


Here's to Homeschooling!

Happy Valentine's Day. Have a great weekend full of love and affection for your friends and family.

 ~Luke Holzmann
Filmmaker, Writer, Expectant Father

*2+2=? is an Algebraic equation. You are solving for an unknown. It's just that in this case, the unknown is a ? instead of an x.

Share this post via email










Submit
10 Comments

2009 Sonlight Scholarship Winners

Share this post via email










Submit

Sonlight students exemplify academic excellence, creativity and servanthood

One glance at what our 2009 Sonlight scholarship winners have accomplished and what they purpose to do, and you may no longer ask the question, "Does homeschooling work?" Instead, you're likely to wonder, "Where do you find students like this!?"

Like many of our Sonlight students, these scholarship winners exemplify academic excellence, leadership, character, mission-mindedness, a heart for learning, creativity and spiritual depth. They not only hope to impact the world in the future, they are transforming their communities and actively serving others now.
Because we encourage personal excellence and quality education, and in light of our mission to equip students to passionately pursue Christ in whatever He calls them to do, we delight to invest in the education of these bright students.

Sonlight will award $82,000 over the next four years to these Sonlight Scholarship winners (we've awarded over half a million dollars in scholarships since we began this competition!). All of these hard-working, talented students have completed at least four Sonlight History / Bible / Literature programs (including high school levels). We look forward to seeing all God does in and through them as they take what they've learned—through Sonlight and through their homeschool experience—onto college and into the world.

Virginia Macfarlan

Virginia "Ginger" Macfarlan,
Winner of $20,000 Award

($5000 each year)

Ginger Macfarlan of Siloam Springs, AR, began writing a weekly column in her hometown newspaper at age nine. Eight years later, as somewhat of a local celebrity, she's written over 400 columns and plans to hone her skills at John Brown University to pursue her creative writing aspirations in freelance work. Her passion is to make God known through the written word.

An eager learner, Ginger agrees with Yeats that, "Education is not the filling of a pail but the lighting of a fire." In her own life, she explains, "The fire for learning has been lit. I look forward to fanning the flame to shine brighter and hotter as I embrace the challenge of college life."

Ginger is a National Merit Commended Student, an award-winning orator and essay winner on the national level, and president of her city's homeschool teen board. She was one of two girls chosen to represent her state as a Senator at the American Legion Girls' Nation in Washington D.C.

She regularly volunteers at Manna Center food bank where she also prepares a quarterly newsletter and coordinates food drive events. She's a member of the Singing Ensemble and Music Ministry at her church.

Winners of $10,000 Awards

($2500 per year)

Leila Shelburne

Leila Shelburne has lived in Mbale, Uganda, for the last 14 years... Her heart for missions spurred on her dream of becoming a physical therapist as she saw the many physical needs of people around her in Africa. She wants to use her education to "shine God's light in the darkness...to show the compassion of Jesus...to heal people's bodies as God works in their hearts and souls." She plans to major in English Literature at Harding University before going on to physical therapy school.

She's volunteered with Children's Hospital in Kenya and medical mission outreaches, ministered to AIDS orphans, faithfully served a Sunday School ministry, began a weekly Bible study for her peers, and used her organizational skills to set up a library and ensure its first 10,000 books made it on the shelves in order.

A gifted athlete and musician, Leila has trained in guitar, piano, recorder, and cello, with a focus on leading worship. Her love for literature has blossomed into a talent for writing poetry and short stories, and she enjoys drawing and photography, capturing in art the many children she serves.

Rebekah Callari

Rebekah Callari of Sarasota, FL, has spent much of her life in the service of others. Her compassion for children and people with disabilities has inspired her to actively volunteer in the preschool and children's ministries of her church.

From working on a meal service staff to acting as a Spanish tutor, from going on mission trips to the Dominican Republic to serving her family in her own home as they battled debilitating illness, her compassionate spirit and willingness to put others first is a common denominator.

A National Merit Semi-Finalist, Rebecca's creativity shines through her gifts in jewelry-making, handcrafts and photography, as well as her work on her yearbook staff. She is a committed and seasoned equestrian.

Passionate about research in autism and diet-related prevention of many diseases, Rebekah plans to major in Microbiology at the University of Central Florida in pursuit of a career as a gastroenterologist.

Anna Castro

From the first drawing she remembers creating at age four, Anna Castro of Royce City, TX, has always loved to tell stories through her art. A talented painter with a knack for technology, she plans to pursue a career in film and computer animation at Full Sail University. Inspired by authors like Lewis and Tolkien, she longs to impact society for Christ through her work. "The church is still fledging in the field of entertainment" she explains, "but it's a tool simply too powerful to dismiss."
Anna won first place and best of show for her oil painting at the State Fair of Texas and enjoys painting sets for her community theatre—as well as acting in the performances. She's sings in her church choir and praise team and plays violin in the orchestra, and also performs with the city orchestra. A natural leader, she hosts a weekly teen Bible study in her home and organized a trip to Europe for a group of teens and their moms.

Winners of $4, 000 Awards

Sonlight will award eight additional students a $1000 scholarship for each year of college (up to four years). We're confident all these winners will make a positive mark in the world and continue on the path of lifelong learning.
Winners in alphabetical order are:

Kyle Clark

Kyle Clark of North Bend, WA, is a National Merit Semi-finalist who plans to study architectural engineering. He's a top national competitor in speech and debate, with many awards in the National Christian Forensics and Communications Association and Lincoln Douglas Values Debate. Both a serious competitor and coach, he led a 32-week values debate course to equip 8-12th graders to promote and defend the Gospel.
He's active in musical theatre, AWANA, Varsity Cross Country, piano composition (Best Composition Award), and performs dances with the Eastside Swing Cats at a variety of venues, from Disneyland to nursing homes, to a summer camp for kids with cancer.

Monica Kehrer

Monica Kehrer of Ringgold, GA, plans to study music education at Bryan College. She's active in ballroom dance, AWANA, piano, band, voice, choir and National Honor Society. She taught swimming with the Red Cross for three years, served as president of 4-H, and volunteers in the preschool ministry at her church.

Caleb Khazoyan

Caleb Khazoyan of Littleton, CO, plans to attend John Brown University in preparation to become a web developer. He's active in speech and debate club, Boy Scouts, Project Cure, web development, and Biotech gaming. He served on a medical team in Iquitos, Peru, and has done independent contract work at Caleb Resources/Pioneers. He's studied piano since age five and continues to hone his skills.

Kristina Okerman

Kristina Okerman of Kobe, Kita-ku, Hyogo, Japan, plans to study education and become a teacher. She helped create an English-teaching program for Japanese children, including doing voice recordings, testing lesson sand learning game ideas. She now teaches basic Japanese to elementary students. She explores her creativity through watercolor painting, desktop publishing and web building with Dreamweaver, PhotoShop, 3D animation and Final Cut. She's the Co-Editor of News of the Network (a monthly email-based newsletter and website).

Jennifer Quan

Jennifer Quan of Huntsville, AL, plans to attend Duke University to further her passion to teach others how to communicate their thoughts and make a difference for God's kingdom. She specializes in debate and public policy speech and has served as both a Student Leader and Head Coach for Milestones Speech and Debate Club, and has also organized and taught summer workshops on debate.
She is Founder and Teacher of a communications and public speaking class at Freedom Academy, a school for underprivileged young men. She is a writer for the Huntsville Times, a Special Olympics volunteer, a volunteer at Redstone's Assisted Care and Living Facility, and member of Young Tang Soo Do studio.

Abigail Sargent

Abigail Sargent of East Barre, VT, has a passion for music, history and literature and is interested in teaching and missions. She plays the Irish fiddle and piano, teaches 1st and 2nd grade Pioneer Club, and has learned the ins and outs of small dairy farm care and management. She enjoys alpine skiing and snowboarding, historical research and costume design/construction, and horseback riding. She's active in a Bible study with her youth group, as well as the Compass mentoring program, and has served on a mission trip to India.

Audrey Stephens

Audrey Stephens of Phnom Penh, Cambodia, plans to build on her love of children by majoring in education at Bob Jones University. She's active in Youth choir, homeschool co-op courses (like Soccer, Literature, Crafts and Botany), and she independently studies American Sign Language. She's a library volunteer, nursery worker, Sunday School teacher, VBS assistant and has served as co-director of a Christmas play. She teaches English to non-native speakers at Heritage International School where she manages two preschool classrooms with a total of 48 three and four-year-olds.

Dylan Wren

Dylan Wren of Long Beach, MS, plans to study electrical engineering at Mississippi State University. He has organized volunteer projects at Long Beach Food Pantry and regularly serves the hungry and the poor at Bible Fellowship Church's Sunday Breakfast. He is a member of the Long Beach Youth Commission, a guitarist for the Christian rock band Malachi, accompanist on bass guitar for his homeschool choir, and a Leader in Training for AWANA. He participated in two week-long mission trips to North Carolina to help F.A.I.T.H. Way, Inc. prepare land and housing for a future children's home.

You could be a winner next year!

Sonlight will increase the number of four-year awards to 13 ($92,000!) for students planning to attend college in the Fall of 2010. Families who've ordered at least five History / Bible / Literature programs since 1999 are eligible. Find out the requirements and complete details for next year's scholarship competition.

Share this post via email










Submit
Tagged | Leave a comment

Like a Kid in a Clicking Store

Share this post via email










Submit

...I know, it should be candy store, but that doesn't have much relevance for the web. So, in typical Luke fashion, I forced a pun into a colloquialism based on a cultural allusion.

I'm sick. I know. But you are free to remind me of that fact <smile>.

First up: A brand new forum to find out about the conventions Sonlight will be attending this year. If you like walking convention floors and want to meet up with some Sonlight folks, here's your source for details.

In other news, Jerri-Ann linked to a post where a woman chats about homeschooling and why she doesn't. She labeled it a "debate," so I, naturally, added my thoughts. I thought my points were solid, and I took the time to write them, so I'm sharing them with you. I'd be very interested in your thoughts on the matter.

Now for the thing that has be totally excited, much like a kid in a candy store, only it's me on the web: We're testing a new feature on Sonlight's Newcomer 1 page. I've been pushing for this thing for a while, and it's cool to see us begin to test it. What is this super-cool, totally awesome, terribly exciting new feature?

Customer action shots--at least, that's what ThinkGeek calls 'em.


Candy Store

Sadly, we are split testing this feature, so you may not see it when you click over. If that happens, there is something you can do...

[<shh> don't tell them I told you this: If you clear your computer's cookies it may give you the picture bar when you refresh the page... granted, that will also kill my ability to track how effective this blog has been, but it's a sacrifice I'm willing to make for you, my close friends and confidants.]

That's all the link-love I have at the moment. But I'm also out of time.

Gotta run before the peoples find out I told you about that the cookie thing. Maybe I can convince them I was talking about sweets; you know, what with the candy theme of this post and all...

 ~Luke Holzmann
Filmmaker, Writer, Expectant Father

Share this post via email










Submit
10 Comments

Feeding the Problem

Share this post via email










Submit

I tried to add an RSS feed of Sonlight's latest News and Announcements to this blog today, but something wasn't working. In fact, it still isn't working.

So I poked around online. Nothing. I searched the Blogger help forum. Still nothing. I even posted a plea for help. Yep--nothing.

I've been stymied by a system over which I have no control, and I have no idea what goes on in the background that could be causing the problem.

And it's really frustrating when that happens.

Granted, learning to let go of control is an important life lesson. Learning to adapt when something refuses to work is another vital skill. But in cases like these, that's not really what's at stake. In this instance, the danger is that I may just give up. There's nothing I can do, and so I must wait for someone else to do something. And that is a very dangerous lesson to learn; it promotes apathy and discourages creative problem solving.

...almost like the bureaucracy of educational systems. There are many aspects of public education--not to mention most other government-driven aspects of life--over which we have very little control. Buying into these systems promotes the idea that we must wait for the government--or other entity of authority--to come save us if something goes wrong. It stifles personal responsibility. In many cases, we end up with no control over what is happening, and have no way of truly finding the source of the problem.

Homeschooling, while potentially messier--like me piecing together code for an RSS widget--offers control and a hands-on approach to any issues that may arise.

May you find ways to overcome the obstacles you encounter today, even if you have to get your hands dirty. And if you're like me, and waiting on "the powers that be," may the red tape be cut, and the issue resolved satisfactorily. Remember: If you are not satisfied with the results, there are other options.

...but you may have to start doing something yourself.

 ~Luke Holzmann
Filmmaker, Writer, Expectant Father

Share this post via email










Submit
Leave a comment

Badges, Trademarks, the States... Oh My!

Share this post via email










Submit

So, I totally recently told you to go hog wild with badges for Sonlight. Well, I just got out of a meeting where I was informed of a very special caveat to this whole thing, and that has to do with our Registered Trademarks (remember when I mentioned those a while back?).

Since I'm not clever enough to figure this all out, I'm getting some help from our lawyers on how to make this great for everyone. If I understand it right, if we don't make a few changes to the badges out there, we could lose control of our trademarks and nefarious people could take it for nefarious purposes. So, the message for today is:


Proceed with Caution

When I know more, I'll let you all know. This isn't fun for me because I love link love from all y'all, and I don't want to stifle that in any way. I'm your biggest fan of your being a fan of Sonlight--believe you me.

So that's got me a little bummed at the moment.

I need something to cheer me up. But what?

Oh, I know!

How about I see just how bad at geography I really am!
That's bound to make me feel chipper again!

Take the States test now! It actually is pretty fun to see just how completely lost I am without Google Maps...


Shannon

 ~Luke Holzmann
Filmmaker, Writer, Expectant Father

Share this post via email










Submit
4 Comments

41,000 and Meetup 2010

Share this post via email










Submit

I pushed a button and sent an email to over 41,000 people today.

It was my first time doing something like that, and I was more than a little stressed. If you got the "Your Sonlight newsletter: A shot of homeschool mom adrenaline" in your inbox and everything worked on the technical side of things, let me know. If it didn't work at all, I don't want to know.

Okay, I do.

But I don't.

So be gentle.

Thanks.

*****

With the newsletter we have officially announced the 2010 Sonlight Meetup which will take place here in Colorado July 2-4th, 2010. That's right: You can come see Sonlight, hang out with other Sonlighters and meet me. How cool is that?

Pretty stinkin' cool, if you ask me.

Which you didn't, directly, but you're reading my blog, so it's almost like you did; at least, enough to make me feel like I am warranted sharing my opinion on this matter with you, my faithful readers--even if you aren't yet a faithful reader and have just stumbled upon this blog and are thinking to yourself, 'Self, what is up with this madman?'

In short: Come to the 2010 Meetup. And, at the very least, go check out the super cool "Event" I just put up on Sonlight's Facebook page.

 ~Luke Holzmann
Filmmaker, Writer, Expectant Father

Share this post via email










Submit
7 Comments